
How federal cuts impact Michigan nonprofits, ARISE! Detroit 19th annual Neighborhoods Day
Season 53 Episode 26 | 26m 46sVideo has Closed Captions
The impact of federal funding cuts on nonprofits and ARISE! Detroit’s 19th annual Neighborhoods Day.
American Black Journal host Stephen Henderson examines the impact of federal funding cuts on local nonprofits with McGregor Fund President Kate Levin Markel and Focus: HOPE CEO Portia Roberson. Plus, Henderson gets details about ARISE! Detroit’s 19th annual Neighborhoods Day from Board Vice Chair Dr. George Swan III. He shares how the event will honor the late ARISE! Detroit Founder Luther Keith.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
American Black Journal is a local public television program presented by Detroit PBS

How federal cuts impact Michigan nonprofits, ARISE! Detroit 19th annual Neighborhoods Day
Season 53 Episode 26 | 26m 46sVideo has Closed Captions
American Black Journal host Stephen Henderson examines the impact of federal funding cuts on local nonprofits with McGregor Fund President Kate Levin Markel and Focus: HOPE CEO Portia Roberson. Plus, Henderson gets details about ARISE! Detroit’s 19th annual Neighborhoods Day from Board Vice Chair Dr. George Swan III. He shares how the event will honor the late ARISE! Detroit Founder Luther Keith.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
How to Watch American Black Journal
American Black Journal is available to stream on pbs.org and the free PBS App, available on iPhone, Apple TV, Android TV, Android smartphones, Amazon Fire TV, Amazon Fire Tablet, Roku, Samsung Smart TV, and Vizio.
Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorship(upbeat music) - Coming up on "American Black Journal," we will examine how federal funding cuts are affecting nonprofits right here in Michigan.
And we'll tell you how one foundation has pledged to help fill the gap.
Plus this year's ARISE Detroit!
Neighborhoods Day is taking on added significance as organizers remember the nonprofit's founder, the late Luther Keith.
Stay where you are, "American Black Journal" starts right now.
- [Narrator 1] From Delta faucets to Behr paint, (uplifting music) Masco Corporation is proud to deliver products that enhance the way consumers all over the world experience and enjoy their living spaces.
Masco, serving Michigan communities since 1929.
Support also provided by: The Cynthia and Edsel Ford Fund for Journalism at Detroit PBS.
- [Narrator 2] The DTE Foundation is a proud sponsor (uplifting music) of Detroit PBS.
Through our giving, we are committed to meeting the needs of the communities we serve statewide to help ensure a bright and thriving future for all.
Learn more at DTEFoundation.com.
- [Narrator 1] Also brought to you by Nissan Foundation and viewers like you.
Thank you!
(upbeat music) - Welcome to "American Black Journal!"
I'm Stephen Henderson, your host.
Federal funding cuts that began in January are now starting to have an impact on the programs, services, and staff of nonprofits here in Michigan.
And they are causing a lot of uncertainty about the future.
In order to help fill the funding gaps, the McGregor Fund has decided to double its payout rate to the foundation's nonprofit partners over the next two years.
Joining me now are McGregor Fund President, Kate Levin Markel and Portia Robeson, she is the CEO of Focus: HOPE.
Welcome to "American Black Journal."
I've wanted for a while to have this conversation and I think now that we are, you know, well into 2025, hey, we can assess what's actually happening, what the impact of all this change in Washington is having on people here.
Kate, I'm gonna start with you.
McGregor funds an awful lot of the organizations that are targets of some of these cuts in Washington.
Let's start just with what you hear and see from your grantees about what this means.
- Thank you Stephen, it's great to be here.
First, I like to think about how there are different things happening at once, and different partners are experiencing these different dynamics.
So the first thing that happened was, there were freezes on money owed- - [Stephen] Right, that had already been allocated.
- That had already been allocated and put into contract and spent because a lot of that funding gets paid by the federal government to organizations on a reimbursement basis.
- That's right.
- So there were just refusals to make good on payments that were frankly, for the most part, illegal, because they'd been appropriated by the Congress.
So those fights, because there have been pushbacks, are working their way through the courts.
So some of that money's freeing up, but in the meantime, there's a starvation effect on organizations.
Then there were different attempts to cut off funding more, a little bit more in line with what we would consider normal.
And then of course we have coming soon at us, future cuts that are going to come out of this congressional budgeting process.
So it's an enormous, complex mix of things, and I'm sure Portia will really be able to help us understand those dynamics as the leader of an organization that received so many different types of funding.
And, but before I turn it over to her, and I do wanna hear, I'll just say this has touched people providing housing, people providing free and emergency food, people providing supports for people to get to work, people providing legal services, people supporting survivors of domestic violence.
There are many examples, sadly, where this has really affected the whole social safety net.
- The social safety net, yeah.
- Across the board.
- And that's most of, or a lot of the work that you're doing.
That's why you're seeing this as closely as you are.
- Absolutely.
- Yeah.
Portia, Focus: HOPE, of course, you are part of that social safety net in a couple of different ways.
But talk about the relationship between the services you provide and the federal funding you get and what happens when that funding is in jeopardy.
- So, as Kate mentioned, the federal freeze on reimbursement dollars was the first, I guess, attack, so to speak.
You know, a Tuesday afternoon, we get word that the dollars had been frozen.
I immediately get on a call with about 75 to 100 other providers of Head Start and Early Head Start, which is one of the components of what Focus: HOPE does.
When I tell you there were literal tears being shed while we were on our Zoom call, because people in much smaller organizations were looking at having to close by the end of the day and layoff people.
Focus: HOPE has about 107 staff members in our early learning program that would have to have been laid off within two to three days, maybe over the weekend, maybe I would have four days to tell people what was going on.
But otherwise, we were looking at having to close that portion of Focus: HOPE.
We then got exempted out, so it's a roller coaster of a day in terms of emotions and what you're thinking you might have to do.
There was a moment when I closed my door and just sort of cried for a moment and then open the door back to try to figure out what to do next.
And so for that period of time, we were exempted out of the freeze.
And then subsequently those freezes were lifted for our time being.
But now we're in the situation where we have a grant application for Head Start and Early Head Start, and we've not heard whether or not we're getting it or not.
So currently we're operating until July 31st, but we don't know quite yet what's gonna happen after that.
The same was true for our senior food program, our commodity supplemental food program.
We were unsure, we got in the extension of the 2023-24, 24-25 budget, we got extended.
So we knew we were gonna be funded there through September.
We now are seeing that there was some money reintroduced into this new budget that's coming along, because there was a point where it was zeroed out.
There was no commodity supplemental food program.
So 43,000 seniors in nine counties in Michigan that are fed by Focus: HOPE each month, no food.
- You don't know.
- Right.
- You don't know what the future is.
Of course, if you talk to the folks in Washington who are doing this, they say, "Well, we have this tremendous spending problem in government.
We overspend terribly and we have to cut back."
And I keep hearing also, "Other people can do this," right?
"Other people than government, other sources than government can provide these services and they will if we pull back."
Is that a reasonable way to think about how this all works?
- No.
- Can we filled gap?
- No.
- No.
Why?
- Well, if you think about it, the government support for all of these critical functions is so large, that individuals and foundations just don't have enough funding to pay for it without a major risk redistribution of wealth in this country, or the largesse of the people with the most money.
Now, the reason these cuts are being made is to pay for tax cuts, which very disproportionately help high-earning and high-asset folks.
So we can pay for those services, but we can't pay for them and then reduce the tax revenue coming in.
So this is a values decision.
This is not just fiscal prudence.
This is a values decision and the way in which it's being done is not the traditional democratic process that we all deserve.
- Yeah.
Yeah.
So, let's talk about the effect of McGregor doubling what it is gonna make available to grantees over the next two years.
What effect might that have?
And what's the strategy, I guess, there, in terms of how it fits in with the cuts that people are gonna be facing?
- I am really pleased to have an opportunity to talk about that.
But before I start, I'd like to ask you, Portia, what is your annual budget for the most recent year?
- About 39, $40 million.
So there's no way that we could go out and find a foundation that could supplement that or that could continue funding us at that level in order to do the work that we do.
And I was at a discussion and somebody, I think it might have been Wendy Jackson from Kresge said, "We can go for about 72 days helping out a nonprofit and then we're out.
Like, we can't do it anymore."
So there are no long-term solutions outside of the federal government continuing to fund some of these programs.
And I think what ultimately becomes the issue is that there are real people on the other ends of this.
This is not some obscure thing that we just want to do.
This is people who, again, throughout nine counties in southeast Michigan, need our food every month, right?
These are seniors who are food insecure.
These are families who rely on Early Head Start, Head Start programs and not just in urban communities, 'cause I think sometimes the language becomes what happens in Detroit, you know, Head Start is a vital part of rural communities.
Like, there are no other options in those communities.
And so one of the things I've been talking about with a lot of our employer partners is, I can give you the best employee in the world and they want to have that job, but they probably have three days of finding somebody to stand in the gap of a Head Start or Early Head Start program.
I always say, "I'm never gonna encourage a parent to leave a 10-year-old at home with a 4-year-old.
So that they can go to work."
That's just not something I'm willing to do, because we know how dangerous that is.
So we need programs like Head Start and Early Head Start, so that this workforce that the government talks about wanting to create.
This, you know, "Everybody's gonna come back to these American jobs!"
Yeah, from where if they don't have childcare?
- Yeah.
So 39, $40 million a year just for Focus: HOPE.
- Right!
- Compare that to how much- - Exactly right!
- How much does McGregor grant to organizations overall?
- In a typical year, we grant $9 million.
- Right, so not even close to just what one organization needs.
- Exactly, exactly.
And so I'd love to answer the questions, 'cause we really believe in transparency and so we doubled our commitment of funding back in March when it was clear what was happening in the community.
We had a meeting with our board and our team and we said, "We just have to do more than we traditionally do."
So, historically, we've granted out about 5%, maybe five and a half percent of our endowment value every year.
So that endowment value fluctuates with investment markets.
But this is not unusual for philanthropy that's set up to last in perpetuity.
But we just said, "We know we can't make up the difference.
But that doesn't take us off the hook from doing everything we can."
We all need to pitch in and do what we can.
A lot of us need to advocate, a lot of us need to step up other ways of supporting community.
And as a funding organization, our job is to dig deeper and just get more money out.
So we feel that clearly, and everyone was in clear agreement around it.
And so we're doing our best.
We can't sit back just because, "Oh, we can't fill the gaps" or "Oh, we can't figure out how to give more money out quickly and perfectly."
We're doing our best.
We're starting with our current partners, trying to identify immediate cash needs, where even buying a few weeks or a few months might keep people in housing, might keep people fed.
More importantly for the long run, well, I shouldn't say more importantly, but like keep people employed in those jobs.
Because if you have to lay off your team, you just can't get them back two weeks later when the funding comes back, people have had to move on and support themselves.
So we can't afford to let people suffer and we can't afford an erosion of our nonprofit safety net, which is what is at stake as you explained.
So, we have a lot of different things we're trying to do.
I'm happy to give more examples or another conversation.
- No, we've only got about 30 seconds left and I, of course, we're gonna have you guys back at some point to talk more about where we are, 'cause this is not ending.
Just quickly, how big a threat is it that Focus: HOPE would have to stop these services If you don't- - Oh, it's huge.
I mean, I talked about the 107 employees, but there are 300 families that will be affected immediately if we have to shut our doors, if we, you know, we have to cut off the Early Head Start and Head Start program.
So it's not, you know, it's a huge community of folks that are looking for places that are safe, that are educational based to put their children every day.
It's what we should be providing for them, right?
And so, yeah, I think about our staff, but I also think about those families who are now thrust into a community that they have no safety net around their children.
- Yeah.
Okay, great to have both of you here.
We will be following up later as well to find out where all this goes.
- Thank you.
- Thanks for having us.
- Up next, we're gonna get the details on this year's ARISE Detroit!
Neighborhoods Day.
But first, here's a clip from a 1991 episode of "Detroit Black Journal" that examines the impact of massive cuts to the state budget back then.
- State Representative Kilpatrick, how was General Assistance targeted by Governor Engler and how did the proponents of General Assistance allow this to happen?
- Unfortunately, when the governor came into office, he announced that he was going to eliminate General Assistance.
We knew then in January and happened, the announcement came shortly after the November election.
We knew in January when we reconvened in a new session of the House of Representatives that we had a fight on our hands.
There was much discussion, much disillusionment.
And then out of all of it, the final vote being 55 to 50 in the House of Representatives on October 10th, I think it was, that did eliminate the General Assistance Program, unfortunately, for our state.
But I wanna say more.
What we're seeing is a national turn away from our people concept from the leaders of this country and the state.
I think General Assistance is just a piece of that.
If you look at the total budget and the vetoes that were just announced and sustained last week, we see that women's programs have been cut and eliminated.
We see that disabled children, and mental health people's services have been disallowed and eliminated.
We see many workers in a flux, wondering if they'll have a job next week.
And I'm here to say, unfortunately, Cliff, we have not seen the brunt of this budget.
The Wayne County and the City of Detroit will lose $500 million from what we had received in our last year's allocations.
- The 19th annual ARISE Detroit!
Neighborhoods Day takes place on Saturday, August 2nd.
This year's theme for the citywide celebration is a day of pride and power.
Community groups, block clubs, faith-based institutions, and others will all host improvement projects, giveaways, art and music festivals, resource fairs, and more.
This year's event will honor the memory and legacy of ARISE Detroit!
's late founder and executive director, Luther Keith.
Here to tell us more is the vice chair of ARISE Detroit!
's Board of Directors, Dr. George Swan III.
George, great to have you here.
- It's a pleasure to be here!
- You know, every year for the last, I don't know, decade or more, I have had a conversation with Luther in advance of Neighborhoods Day.
It's a sad moment, I guess, that I'm talking to you this year instead of him.
But you know, I am glad that you're here and I'm really glad that this is still a powerful and important event in Detroit.
And Luther would want that.
- He is an inspiration behind this, but also inspiring so many other people.
You know, we grew before the pandemic.
They had more than 400 different organizations giving simultaneously thirty events on a single day.
- [Stephen] On a single day.
- And if you think about that, this is the only such event in the country, so we have a lot of good organizations that are making attempts to do neighborhood cleanups.
They're doing things to bring together certain communities.
They're able to inspire all types of activities, but not on the same day citywide.
- [Stephen] Right.
Right.
- And if you think about the power that suggests, it all came from a vision of Luther saying, "We ought be part of the change.
Let's do something that's going to be creative, inspirational, that's gonna bring people together, bridge the intergenerational gaps."
And it's kind of hard with his infectious nature to tell Luther, "No."
- [Stephen] (laughs) It was, it was impossible.
- It was impossible, right?
And so, I have no question.
- You tried!
- I tried, I tried, yeah.
- So let's talk about this year and what might be different about the Neighborhoods Day.
I suspect there will be a very different feeling about the celebrations this year.
But every year, Luther would talk about things that maybe we weren't gonna have, what maybe were happening this year that didn't happen the year before.
- Well, first of all, we have patent back in the growth mode.
So right after the pandemic or during the pandemic, we had a whole experience of, Create in your own space.
- [Stephen] Right!
(laughs) - So it's sort of- - You couldn't see each other!
- You couldn't see each other.
We also knew that there were people who were very comfortable and some who were not very comfortable in having public events and doing things.
And so that became a very constraining, kind of period of time.
But now we are growing and more people seem to be interested in celebrating Luther's legacy and they're signing up, and the joy of it is that there is a sense of excitement, of energy, of compassion, and commitment that this is indeed going to continue.
And we're looking at the 20th as being a little celebration of the fact that this all started out with a dream on a napkin.
- [Stephen] Right!
(laughs) - Luther would told the story, you know, he just said, "Something has to change, and so, be part of the change."
He actually came up with a word that we were using called a ARISEcification.
- [Stephen] Yeah, I've heard him use that.
- Yeah, and the idea is that, it's not just a static kind of thing, it's an ongoing movement, and so we actually encourage people to be part of the change to arise, to become, to embrace ARISEcification.
Not just on that one day, but throughout their lives and throughout their communities.
- All the time.
- All the time.
And so it's amazing when you think of the fact that there are so many organizations, so many people, who are looking at creative ways of expressing themselves.
So whether it's it's music, whether it's cleanups, whether it's doing volunteer work, whether it's helping seniors, helping young people learn new skills, whether it's artists who are having their own shows and try and do demonstrations.
- [Stephen] You might know a little of that.
- I might know a little bit about that.
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
That shameless plug, on my Docswan.
But the idea is that they're doing things that help to educate, to enlighten, to create some joy and sense satisfaction, and being part of the city, being part of communities and being able to know each other.
You know, we live in an environment where a lot of folk don't know the person who lives next door to them.
- [Stephen] Right!
- And so this brings people into their yards and on their porches into the streets, into parks and into places that, hopefully, they will continue to use and to communicate with each other to facilitate the- - Even if it's just to say hello.
- Just to say hello!
It's amazing!
I remember there was a time when I first got onto the board and I tried to get to so many events at one time, see, I mean, I could make it, and it was interesting.
(Stephen laughing) I was driving all across the city, it was, and I was like, "All right!"
Because different events started at different times.
You know, I was speeding somewhere and thinking, "How am I gonna tell law enforcement, 'Well, I'm doing this because we're ARISE Detroit!
You know, like, this especial organization.
I don't, you know, you can't stop me now!'"
- "I've gotta make it!"
- "I've gotta make it there!"
But this just tells you the kind of energy and people are doing things and we are a small organization.
That's the other side to it.
Is that Luther ran a very tight ship, a very small staff ship.
But we had hundreds of volunteers.
And that's the magic of it all, is that you don't have to pay people to do things that express their joy, express their satisfaction and their- - It's just incredible.
- It is.
It really is.
- So, I wanna talk just a little about the organization and it's future.
You know, lots of people start lots of things and when they're gone, there's sometimes a question about, "Well, can we continue this?"
And it's really good to see that, that ARISE just is rolling on.
It keeps going.
- If we didn't have ARISE, we should create an organization like it.
- [Stephen] We would have to invent it.
- That's right.
That's right.
And it's not to say there aren't other organizations that are trying to do, or doing, not trying, they're doing things that are similar.
But again, they're very unique, they're very individual.
There's singular types of things.
And we have a commitment as part of the board as well as part of the organization to ensure this continues that legacy of Luther, that ARISEcification, that we have people understand they can be part the change.
And so we are committed to celebrate it.
We're committed to maintain the, to continue it.
And we're planning now for the 20th ARISE Detroit!
Neighborhoods Day.
- Yeah.
- Yes.
- Yeah.
What do you tell people who wanna do this, who maybe haven't participated before?
Because each year you have more people.
- That's right.
- Who stand up and say, "Our neighborhood's gonna be part of this!"
What do you tell 'em about that energy?
To just go and do it.
To not worry about whether it's gonna work, or whether it's gonna be big or small.
Just to lean into the idea of it.
- What's nice is that there's no sanctioned event, there's no authority from up high- - You do what you want.
- telling you what to do.
But we do make sure you wanna do things that are safe for people.
That you ensure- - No fireworks.
- No fireworks shows, you know?
No running off of, pulling off of bridges, things like that.
But you can do things that are very simple, even in your own yard.
Planting flowers, showing young people how to grow vegetables.
Those are the kinds of things that you can start small.
Cleaning up a park, being able to go pick up the trash along a block or a street and then having others walk along with you while you do that.
Those are the kinds of things that help build a community.
- They're all possible.
- They're all possible.
So it doesn't mean that you have to have thousands of volunteers.
You have to have a budget of millions of dollars.
You can start with a budget of zero and your feet and your arms and your hands and your thoughts and your energy and you can make it happen.
- Yeah.
- Yeah!
- All right, well, George, it is great to have you here.
We look forward to Neighborhoods Day and great things from ARISE Detroit!
- Thank you so much for having me.
- Yeah.
- Thank you.
(upbeat music) - So that'll do it for us this week.
You can find out more about our guests at americanblackjournal.org and you can connect with us anytime on social media.
Take care, and we'll see you next time.
- [Narrator 1] From Delta faucets to Behr paint, (uplifting music) Masco Corporation is proud to deliver products that enhance the way consumers all over the world experience and enjoy their living spaces.
Masco, serving Michigan communities since 1929.
Support also provided by: The Cynthia and Edsel Ford Fund for Journalism at Detroit PBS.
- [Narrator 2] The DTE Foundation is a proud sponsor (upbeat music) of Detroit PBS.
Through our giving, we are committed to meeting the needs of the communities we serve statewide, to help ensure a bright and thriving future for all.
Learn more at DTEFoundation.com.
- [Narrator 1] Also brought to you by Nissan Foundation, and viewers like you.
Thank you!
(uplifting music)
19th annual Neighborhoods Day honors legacy of ARISE Detroit! Founder Luther Keith
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: S53 Ep26 | 8m 49s | Michigan nonprofit leaders share how federal funding cuts are impacting their organizations. (8m 49s)
Federal funding cuts cause Michigan nonprofits to adjust programs and services
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: S53 Ep26 | 13m 31s | Michigan nonprofit leaders share how federal funding cuts are impacting their organizations. (13m 31s)
Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorshipSupport for PBS provided by:
American Black Journal is a local public television program presented by Detroit PBS